
Comic book condition documentation works best as a dated record for each book: what the book is, the date, a full set of unedited photos and short videos, each defect with its size and place, and where the book is stored. Add a new dated entry after anything that could change the book, such as pressing, cleaning, a move, a sale or damage.
A record is evidence, not a verdict: it lets anyone compare the book in hand with the same book on a known date.
What is a comic book condition record?
A comic book condition record is a dated, per-book file of photos, short videos and written notes that shows what one copy looked like on one day. Each later entry adds a new date, so the file shows the book over time.
The date is the point. Pages tone as paper ages, a spine can pick up stress lines when someone reads the book, and a leak or a fall can stain a cover or bend a corner in seconds. "It was near mint when I bought it" cannot be checked; a dated corner close-up with the note "top-right corner sharp, no bends" can.
A baseline entry is the first complete record of a book, made the day it arrives or before anything is done to it. Every later entry is compared with it.
What to record in each entry
Each entry records the book's identity, its copy marks, the date and source, the media, the findings, what only you know, and where the book is kept.
| Part | What to write | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Identity | Title, issue, publisher, cover date, printing or variant | Separates it from reprints and variants |
| Copy marks | Production flaws, an arrival date, a pencil price | Identifies this copy |
| Date and source | Capture date, who shot it, whose grade it is | An undated grade cannot be compared |
| Media | Both covers, four corners, the centerfold, a spine pass, a page flip | The same set makes entries comparable |
| Findings | Each defect's size and place, and whether it breaks the color | Shows new or growing defects |
| Disclosures | Pressing, cleaning, repairs, signature details, odor, page feel; "not known" if unsure | Photos cannot settle these |
| Storage | Room, box, slot, sleeve and board | Tells you what to check after a leak |
Sizes matter because the published grade descriptions draw their lines by size. A 1/16-inch bend that does not break the color still fits 9.4 NM, while a 1/4-inch crease fits 8.0 VF only if it is unnoticeable and leaves the color unbroken. "Small bend, top-right" cannot tell those apart. Lay a ruler beside the book, never on it, and write sizes in fractions of an inch.
Record production flaws as carefully as damage. The E-Man #1 sample report lists a slight miswrap that leaves a narrow unprinted strip along the front spine edge. Noted in a baseline, the strip is on record as a production flaw, not new wear.
For the inspection order, follow how to grade a raw comic at home; for the shots, see how to photograph comics so the flaws show.
Shoot every full entry the same way: the book out of its sleeve, on the same surface, in the same light, from the same distance. Then a difference between two entries is a difference in the book, not in the photos.
When to add a new dated entry
Add an entry after any event that could change the book, and before the book leaves your hands.
| Event | When | What the entry needs |
|---|---|---|
| The book arrives | Before you re-bag or store it | The parcel before opening, the full set, the seller's photos, listing and receipt |
| Pressing or cleaning | Before it goes out and when it comes back | The full set both times, plus any paperwork from the service |
| A move, a loan or a show | Before it leaves and when it is back in storage | Covers, corners and spine, plus the storage place |
| Damage | As soon as you find it, before anything is done to it | Photos of the damage with a ruler beside it; the full set once it is safe to handle |
| A sale or a submission for grading | Just before you pack it | The full set |
| A routine re-check | On a schedule you choose | The full set only if something changed |
For pressing, the before entry matters most. Pressing can flatten a bend, but it cannot remove a color break, and the two entries show which defects stayed. Write "pressed" in the record, and say so when you sell.
For the storage habits that keep later entries uneventful, see bagging and storage that protects the condition you recorded.
How to name and back up your files
Keep the originals unedited, name each file by date, book and view, and keep at least two copies in two places.
- Give each book a short record ID, such as BK-0042, and use it in every file name.
- Make one folder per book and, inside it, one folder per entry, named date first (2026-10-31, not 12-14-26) so the folders sort in time order.
- Copy the photos and videos from the phone at full size. A chat app or a social site can shrink the files and strip the capture date stored inside them.
- Rename each copy by date, ID and view, and keep its original file type.
- Never edit an original. Save any edit for a listing as a separate copy with "edit" in its name.
- Keep the written entry and any report PDF in the same folder.
- Keep at least two copies in places as far apart as practical, such as a home computer and a cloud account or an off-site drive.
These steps follow the Library of Congress advice on keeping personal digital photos (as of October 2026), which also says to check at least once a year that the files still open and to copy them to new media every five years or sooner if needed.
The capture date stored inside each photo comes from the phone's clock, so keep the clock set to update automatically. Example layout (the ID and date are examples):
BK-0042 Title and issue/
record.txt (record and change log)
2026-10-31 baseline/
2026-10-31_BK-0042_front.jpg
2026-10-31_BK-0042_back.jpg
2026-10-31_BK-0042_corner-TL.jpg (and TR, BL, BR)
2026-10-31_BK-0042_centerfold.jpg
2026-10-31_BK-0042_spine.mp4
2026-10-31_BK-0042_flip.mp4
2026-10-31_BK-0042_report.pdf
YYYY-MM-DD moved/
How a grade report works as a dated snapshot
A grade report works as a dated snapshot when it cannot change after it is issued, shows its date and method, and keeps the evidence it graded from. We make NuGrade, an AI-assisted grading app for raw comics, and our reports work this way:
- Each report grades the book on the 10-point grading scale and cites the photo or video frame behind each finding.
- Each report shows the date it was graded and the methodology version that produced it. The public sample reports read "Graded September 30, 2026" and "NuGrade v1.12".
- A report never changes, so old reports keep their grade when the grader improves.
- A regrade makes a new report with a new ID and QR code. The old report stays available at its URL unless the owner deletes it. Anyone can open either available report at the report lookup without an app or an account.
So two reports of one book are a before and an after, each with its own date, version and media. Neither report mentions the other, so the comparison is yours:
- Match findings by place: the same corner, staple or edge.
- Mark each finding as new, grown, unchanged or gone.
- Open the cited photo or frame in both reports before you trust a difference, because glare can hide a defect in one capture and not the other.
- Check the versions. If they differ, part of the difference can come from the method, not the book.
A report is an opinion limited to what the photos and video show. It does not replace professional grading, which is still the right choice for a high-value book. It cannot smell the book or feel its pages, and it lists restoration as Unverified when the photos cannot establish it.
Here is a baseline entry filled from the E-Man #1 sample report (Charlton Comics, cover-dated October 1973). The facts come from the report; the lines in angle brackets are the owner's to fill.
ENTRY 2026-09-30 (graded date) Reason: baseline
Book: E-Man #1, Charlton Comics, October 1973
Media: 7 photos (both covers, 4 corners, centerfold)
2 videos (spine pass, page flip)
Findings: 1. Production: slight miswrap, a narrow unprinted
strip along the front spine edge
2. Production: small dark mark at the left edge
of the back cover, likely bindery or printing
Pages: Cream to Off-White; all 36 accounted for
Staples: no findings
Restoration: None detected (photos can miss skilled work)
Grade: 9.2 NM-, range 8.5 VF+ to 9.4 NM
Source: NuGrade report NG-Y1ZW2NQN-RMEV, v1.12
Disclosed: <survey answers>
Storage: <room, box, slot>
Where a dated record helps: sales, shipping, insurance and estates
A dated record helps whenever someone asks what the book looked like before: in a sale, a shipping dispute, an insurance claim or an estate. Whether it is enough is for the insurer, carrier, marketplace or court to decide.
| Situation | What the record shows | What to do first |
|---|---|---|
| Selling | The condition on a date, with photos a buyer can compare with the listing | Give the entry date with any grade, and make a new entry if the book changed |
| A dispute after shipping | The book as you packed it | Make a full entry before you pack; read the carrier's and marketplace's claim rules |
| An insurance claim | What you owned, and its condition before the loss | Ask your insurer now what it accepts |
| An estate | What each book is, where it is, and where its files are | Tell your executor where the archive is and how to open it |
For insurance, the Federal Emergency Management Agency's guide Document and Insure Your Property (FEMA P-1097, July 2018, still posted on Ready.gov as of October 2026) pairs photos or video with written descriptions, suggests an appraisal for valuable items, and says to keep the inventory where you can reach it after a disaster. It also notes that policies differ and that many set time limits for claims. Only your insurer can say what it will accept, so ask before you need to file:
- Is my collection covered, and is there a limit for collectibles?
- Do you want an appraisal, and from whom?
- Which records do you accept, and how soon after a loss must I file?
For an estate, put a one-page index at the top of the archive: one line per book with its record ID, title, location, latest entry date and latest report ID. A record is not an appraisal, so an executor who needs values may still need one. Keep the record private, because it lists what you own and where it is.
A condition record and change log you can copy
Keep one record file per book, with the change log at the top and an entry block for each date. For a single inspection in more detail, use the blank condition record in the home-grading guide.
BOOK RECORD
Record ID:
Title and issue:
Publisher, cover date:
Printing, variant:
Copy marks:
Acquired (date, from whom, receipt):
Storage (room, box, slot, sleeve and board):
File copies (where, date last checked):
ENTRY YYYY-MM-DD
Reason (baseline, event, re-check):
Shot by:
Media folder:
Photos: front, back, corners TL TR BL BR, centerfold, extras
Videos: spine pass, page flip
Findings (worst first; size, place, color broken Y/N):
1.
2.
Page color: Pages counted:
Disclosed (pressing, cleaning, repairs, signature, odor, feel):
Not known:
Grade band and source (self, or report ID and version):
Report (ID, URL, graded date, version, PDF saved Y/N):
Changed since the last entry:
CHANGE LOG: record ID, title and issue
Date Event Change seen Media Report
YYYY-MM-DD baseline first entry full set ID, version
YYYY-MM-DD
Events: arrived, re-check, moved, re-bagged, pressed, cleaned,
damaged, lent, displayed, submitted, shipped, sold
Frequently asked questions
What should a comic book condition record include?
A comic book condition record should include the book's identity, the date, a full set of unedited photos and short videos, each defect with its size and place, what only the owner knows (such as pressing or odor), and where the book is stored.
How often should you update a comic's condition record?
Add a dated entry after any event that could change the book, such as pressing, cleaning, a move, damage or a sale, and before the book leaves your hands. Between events, re-check the book on a schedule you choose.
Is a condition record enough for an insurance claim?
Only your insurer can say. Ask it, before you need to file, which records it accepts and whether it wants an appraisal, then keep your record in that form.
Does a new NuGrade report replace the old one?
No. A regrade makes a new report with its own ID, date and methodology version. The old report stays available at its URL unless the owner deletes it. When both reports are available, they show the book before and after.



