What do you actually keep after selling a comic?

The cost to sell comic books online, line by line: selling, processing and per-order fees, shipping, supplies, returns and sales tax, with example math.

A sleeved Jungle Relay comic sits beside a mailer, backing boards, a calculator and a blank notepad.

The cost to sell a comic book online is everything that comes out of the sale before the money is yours: the marketplace selling fee, payment processing, any per-order or listing fee, optional promotion, the shipping label, packing supplies and a reserve for returns. What you keep, your net proceeds, is the price plus the shipping the buyer paid, minus all of those.

Your profit is what is left after you also subtract what you paid for the book, and sales tax the marketplace collects stays out of both numbers. Every rate below is an example, not any marketplace's real fee, so use the numbers on your own marketplace's current fee page.

How to calculate what you keep from a comic sale

Take every cost of the sale out of the money the buyer paid you, then take out what you paid for the book. Net proceeds are the money a sale leaves you after every fee and cost of that sale. Profit is net proceeds minus what you paid for the book, so a sale can bring money in and still lose money.

money in       = item price + shipping the buyer paid
                 (not the sales tax the marketplace collects)
net proceeds   = money in - every fee and cost of the sale
profit or loss = net proceeds - what you paid for the book

Work it out per sale: a monthly total hides the sales that lost money among the ones that made it.

Every cost of selling a comic online, line by line

An online sale can carry up to ten separate costs. Some are a percentage of the order, some are a fixed amount, and some are your choice.

CostHow it is charged
Selling feeA percentage of the order
Payment processingOn some marketplaces a percentage plus a fixed amount; on others part of the selling fee
Per-order feeA fixed amount on each order
Listing feeA fixed amount per listing, on some marketplaces after a set number of free listings
PromotionOn some marketplaces a percentage you choose, charged when a sale follows a click on your ad
Shipping labelSet by the weight, size, distance and service of the packed parcel
Packing suppliesSleeve, board, two rigid boards or a mailer, and tape
Report or gradingA fixed cost per book, if you paid for one
Returns reserveAn amount you set aside from each sale
What you paidThe price, plus the shipping and tax you paid to get the book

The fee base can make a percentage bigger than it looks

The fee base is the amount a percentage fee is charged on. Some large marketplaces charge their selling fee on the whole order total, including the shipping the buyer paid and the sales tax they collected, and some charge payment processing the same way. On those, a $6 shipping charge carries a fee too. Find the sentence on the fee page that says what the percentage applies to.

Returns cost more than the refund

A return can cost you both labels and any fees the marketplace keeps. Some large marketplaces let a buyer return an item that does not match its description even when the listing says no returns, and the seller pays the return shipping. Read the return policy of the marketplace you use.

A returns reserve is money you set aside from each sale to cover the returns you expect. With example numbers: if 1 sale in 20 comes back and each return costs you $15, set aside $0.75 per sale.

The part you control is the description. State each defect with its size and place on the book, and photograph it so the flaw shows.

A report or professional grading

A report or professional grading bought for this sale is part of its cost. A report from NuGrade, an AI-assisted grading app for raw comics, costs one credit (current credit prices), and a buyer can open it by its ID at the report lookup page without the app. It is an opinion limited to what the photos and video show, and it does not replace professional grading for a valuable book.

Professional grading adds its fee, shipping and insurance both ways, and the wait. See the break-even math for grading a comic and the grading services compared. Either cost weighs most on a low price: a $5 example report would take more than half of an $8 sale.

What you paid for the book

Count the price, the shipping and any tax you paid to get the book. Split a lot's price across its books, evenly or by value; an even split makes the best book look more profitable than it is.

Why sales tax the marketplace collects is not your money

Sales tax that a marketplace collects from your buyer belongs to the state. The marketplace adds it to the buyer's total and sends it on, so it never belongs in your money in or your profit.

A marketplace facilitator law is a state law that makes an online marketplace collect sales tax on the sales it handles for its sellers and pay it to the state. Many states have one, and your state's revenue department can tell you the current rule.

Two things follow for your math:

  1. Leave the tax out. If an order page shows a total with tax, subtract the tax first.
  2. Check the fee base. Where the percentage is charged on the total with tax, you pay a fee on money you never keep. The examples below include this.

On your own website or at a show, collecting sales tax can be your job, so check with your state's revenue department. Outside the US, check the VAT or GST rules with your tax authority.

Worked examples: a $60 comic and an $8 comic

With the same example fees, a $60 comic nets $41.55, and an $8 comic with free shipping loses $1.26 before you count what you paid for it. These are example numbers, not quotes and not any marketplace's real fees. Both use an example selling fee of 13 percent of the order total, including shipping and an example 7 percent sales tax, with payment processing included.

EXAMPLE A: a $60 raw comic, buyer pays shipping (example numbers)
Item price                                  60.00
Shipping the buyer paid                    + 6.00
Money in                                    66.00
(Sales tax the buyer paid, 7%: 4.62. Not yours.)

Selling fee, 13% of 70.62 (with tax)       - 9.18
Payment processing (included)              - 0.00
Per-order fee                              - 0.40
Promotion, 3% of 70.62                     - 2.12
Shipping label                             - 5.50
Packing supplies                           - 1.50
Condition report                           - 5.00
Returns reserve                            - 0.75
Net proceeds                                41.55

Costs take $24.45, about 37 percent, of the $66 the buyer paid you. Profit depends on what you paid:

What you paid for the book (example)Net proceedsProfit or loss
$50, bought last month at full price$41.55-$8.45
$35, bought at a show$41.55+$6.55
$5, an even share of a $150 lot of 30 books$41.55+$36.55

A $60 sale of a $50 book is not a $10 profit. Here it is an $8.45 loss, and even without the report and the promotion it nets $48.67, still $1.33 short.

EXAMPLE B: an $8 comic, free shipping, no promotion or report
(example numbers)
Item price                                   8.00
Shipping the buyer paid                    + 0.00
Money in                                     8.00
(Sales tax the buyer paid, 7%: 0.56. Not yours.)

Selling fee, 13% of 8.56 (with tax)        - 1.11
Per-order fee                              - 0.40
Shipping label                             - 5.50
Packing supplies                           - 1.50
Returns reserve                            - 0.75
Net proceeds                               - 1.26
What you paid for the book                 - 3.00
Profit or loss                             - 4.26

The label and supplies alone take $7.00 of the $8.00 price. Charge the buyer $5.00 for shipping instead, and the selling fee rises to $1.81 on a $13.91 total, net proceeds come to $3.04, and the profit over the $3.00 book is 4 cents. The fee on that $5.00 and its tax comes to $0.70.

Why cheap comics lose money online, and what to do

Low-priced comics can lose money because most selling costs are fixed. The label, supplies, per-order fee and returns reserve cost about the same on an $8 book as on an $80 book, while the percentage fees shrink with the price.

Your break-even price is the lowest price at which a sale pays back what you paid for the book. With free shipping, estimate it like this:

break-even price = (fixed costs + what you paid)
                   / (1 - percentage fees as a share of the price)

Example B numbers (examples, not quotes):
fixed costs      = 5.50 + 1.50 + 0.40 + 0.75 = 8.15
percentage fees  = 13% of (price + 7% tax) = 13.91% of the price
break-even price = (8.15 + 3.00) / (1 - 0.1391) = 12.95

With these example costs, a book that cost you $3 loses money below about $12.95. Run it with your own costs, then pick a response:

  • Sell them as a lot or a run. One label, one per-order fee and one set of supplies then cover many books.
  • Offer combined shipping. A buyer who adds a second book shares one label.
  • Set a floor. Do not list a single book below your break-even price.
  • Sell the cheapest books in person, at a show or a local sale, with no label or packing.
  • Do not cut the packing. A package that lets a corner bend can turn a small profit into a return. See how to pack a comic so the corners survive the trip.

Income tax: keep records and check the current rules

Income tax is a separate question from sales tax, and the answer depends on where you live and your situation. This guide gives no tax advice.

In the United States, a marketplace or payment app may send you Form 1099-K. As of October 2026, the IRS page on what to do with Form 1099-K says its gross amount is not adjusted for fees, refunds or shipping, and that a loss on the sale of a personal item cannot be deducted. The IRS also says to report income whether or not you receive the form (understanding your Form 1099-K).

The reporting thresholds have changed more than once in recent years, so this guide does not state one. Keep each sale's worksheet with the receipt for what you paid, and check the current rules with the IRS, your country's tax authority or a tax professional.

A blank worksheet and a fee check you can copy

Copy both into a notes app or a spreadsheet. Fill in the fee check first, from your marketplace's current fee page, and date it, because fees change.

NET-PROCEEDS WORKSHEET (one sale)
Book:                               Date sold:
Marketplace:                        Fees checked on:

Item price                                  ______
Shipping the buyer paid                   + ______
Money in                                    ______
Sales tax collected (not yours)             ______

Selling fee: ___% of ______               - ______
Payment processing: ___% + $___           - ______
Per-order fee                             - ______
Listing and store fees                    - ______
Promotion fee: ___% of ______             - ______
Shipping label                            - ______
Packing supplies                          - ______
Report or professional grading            - ______
Returns reserve                           - ______
Net proceeds                                ______

What you paid (price + shipping + tax)    - ______
Profit or loss                              ______
FEE CHECK (from the current fee page)
Selling fee rate for comics: ____ %
Charged on: item / item + shipping / item + shipping + tax
Payment processing: included / ____ % + $____
Per-order fee: $____ (does it change with the order size?)
Listing fee: $____ (free listings each month: ____)
Promotion: ____ % (charged on what, and when?)
International sale or currency conversion: ____ %
Store fee: $____ a month, divided by that month's sales
Refunds: which fees come back when you refund a sale?
Payouts: is a standard transfer free? An instant one?

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to sell a comic book online?

It depends on the marketplace and the price. Add the selling fee, payment processing, any per-order and listing fees, promotion, the shipping label, packing supplies and a returns reserve; fixed costs take a larger share of a low price.

Is the sales tax a buyer pays part of my sale?

No. When a marketplace collects sales tax, it sends that money to the state, so leave it out of your money in and your profit. On some marketplaces, though, the selling fee is charged on a total that includes the tax.

Why did my $8 comic sale lose money?

Most selling costs are fixed. A shipping label, packing supplies and a per-order fee cost about the same at any price, so on a low-priced book they can take more than the sale brings in.

Do I owe income tax on comics I sell online?

It depends on where you live, your situation and the current rules. Keep a worksheet and a purchase receipt for each sale, and check with the IRS, your country's tax authority or a tax professional.

Try NuGrade

Grade your next raw book from your phone.

Guided photos and video, a 10-point grade with every finding tied to the photo it came from, and a report link buyers can check. New accounts start with complimentary credits, no card required.

Open a real report first

Available now for iPhone and Android

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play